Eyeliner Swatches & Comparison

Hey guys! So today im going to be doing 3 eyeliner comparisons and swatches using the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencil , Nyx Auto eye pencil, and the Maybelline Expert Wear 

All of the eyeliners are in the color black.

So pictured above is the swatches on my hand of the 3 eyeliners.

Far left is the Nyx eyeliner

Middle is the Maybelline Expert Wear

And on the Right is the Urban decay 24/7 eyeliner

So as you can tell from the picture the Urban decay eyeliner is so much more darker than the other two. But the creamy consistency is almost the exact

same as the Maybelline one. The maybelline and Urban Decay are very similar in consistency compared to the nyx. The nyx has more of a rough pencil type consistency. 

Now here pictured is all three of them smudged on my hand. The maybelline after just one smudge is almost completely faded. Now the nyx and urban decay have more staying power although the nyx pencil is not ment to be a smudged eyeliner. 

So my final review on this is that my favorite is the Urban Decay. The creamy texture won me over. This pencil is perfect for a smudged eyeliner look.Definitely worth the price 

If you want to know where i got these 3 eyeliners:

Ulta

(Urban decay $19.00) 

Target

(Maybelline $6.00)

Nyx.com

(Nyx $4.50)